Blackhawk Network CEO Talbott Roche on why stored value could become one of retail’s most consequential advantages in agentic commerce.
Retail has spent decades getting better at persuading people. Better creative. Better targeting. Better placement. Better timing.
Now a different kind of decision-maker is entering the picture. It doesn’t wander past an endcap. It doesn’t admire your packaging. And it may eliminate your brand from consideration before a human ever sees it.
That was the uncomfortable premise running through my recent Customerland conversation with Talbott Roche, CEO and president of Blackhawk Network.
But the more interesting part was what followed: brands may already possess a substantial advantage in this emerging environment. They’ve just filed it under gift cards, loyalty, returns, and promotions.
The question is whether a shopping agent can find it.
The new consideration set
Roche describes agentic commerce in three chapters: discoverability, assisted shopping with a human in the loop, and automated purchases.
That sequence matters. Retailers don’t have to wait for autonomous shopping to become commonplace before their economics start changing. The first disruption happens when an agent helps decide which brands deserve consideration.
A brand can lose there without losing a price comparison, delivering a bad experience, or disappointing a customer. It can simply fail to appear.
Roche argues that merchants will need to make their offerings intelligible through structured data, reviews, and third-party signals. That shifts some of the work of persuasion into the systems that describe products, availability, and terms.
Creative still matters. People still have preferences. But a beautiful brand story has limited commercial value in a shopping journey that never encounters it.
The practical implication: being understood by an agent becomes part of being available to a customer.
Blackhawk has moved beyond the rack
If your mental picture of Blackhawk is a rack of gift cards near a grocery store checkout, you’re looking at its origin story.
In our conversation, Roche described a business operating across roughly 30 countries, handling about $40 billion in annual volume, with 70% of its business now digital. Its reach includes digital gift experiences, business rewards, incentives, and distribution. She also described hosting e-gift capabilities for more than 700 leading brands.
Those figures help explain why Blackhawk has a useful vantage point. It operates where brands, payments, distribution, and consumers intersect.
“We think of payments more as a platform for engagement,” Roche told me.
That framing expands the strategic role of stored value. A gift card carries an economic relationship with a brand. A reward can give someone a reason to return. A credit can determine where a purchase makes the most sense.
Agentic shopping could make those relationships more consequential—provided they become visible at the moment of choice.
The money already in the relationship
Consider a simple hypothetical.
A consumer asks an agent to find a pair of running shoes. Two retailers carry the same pair at comparable prices. One can deliver tomorrow. The other can deliver the following day.
Now add a $75 gift card the consumer already holds at the second retailer.
The decision has changed. Depending on the consumer’s priorities, the available balance could outweigh the delivery difference. An agent that never discovers that balance makes its recommendation from an incomplete picture.
The retailer could spend money acquiring a customer who already has money committed to shopping there.
That is an expensive failure of visibility.
Roche characterized stored value as approximately $250 billion of purchase intent in the United States and roughly $650 billion globally. Those are her estimates from the conversation. The strategic point is the existing economic connection: value that gives consumers a reason to choose a particular brand.
Gift cards, loyalty points, return credits, and coupons have different funding structures and redemption rules. They cannot be treated as interchangeable dollars. But each can alter the economics of a purchase.
For an agent evaluating options, those differences are inputs worth knowing.
Checkout is already late
Most merchants encounter stored value near the end of a transaction. Enter the code. Apply the credit. Redeem the points.
By then, the consumer has largely decided where to shop.
Agentic commerce creates the possibility of moving that information earlier, into discovery and comparison. A balance or benefit could help determine which merchant gets considered in the first place.
That is the larger opportunity in Roche’s argument that stored value should become a contextual, ongoing marketing surface.
It also raises a more demanding question than “Do we accept gift cards?”
Can an authorized agent determine what value this customer holds, where it applies, and what conditions govern its use?
A balance without eligibility rules can mislead. A coupon without exclusions can produce a bad recommendation. Outdated information can turn apparent value into a frustrating checkout.
The work involves making the value reliable enough to inform a decision.
Permission is part of the product
Roche emphasized opt-in engagement, and that deserves attention.
A customer possessing a gift card does not automatically give every intermediary permission to inspect it. Connecting value to the correct person, establishing authorization, and controlling access are distinct requirements.
The same applies to security. Making balances easier to discover creates obligations around who can see them and what they can do with that information.
There is also a distribution question: whose agent gets access, through which interface, and on what terms?
Blackhawk’s infrastructure and brand relationships give it a credible position from which to pursue these opportunities. Our conversation described a direction of travel; it did not establish that a universal, permissioned view of every consumer’s stored value already exists.
That gap is where much of the commercial work will happen.
Redemption is the point
The conversation’s most revealing line concerned the economics of the customer relationship.
“We want to be long-term greedy with the consumer, not short-term,” Roche said.
Her emphasis was on redemption, repeat spending, and long-term customer value rather than breakage.
That is the right strategic test. Unused value may produce a financial benefit in some circumstances. Redeemed value creates an opportunity for another transaction, another experience, and another reason to return.
Agents could help activate that value. Whether they produce profitable incremental spending will still need to be measured.
For brands, the immediate assignment is clear: understand the value customers already hold and determine whether it can participate in the shopping journeys now taking shape.
The next competitive advantage may already be sitting in your customers’ accounts.
If their agents can’t see it, it may never enter the decision.
Listen to the full Customerland conversation with Talbott Roche, CEO and president of Blackhawk Network, for more on stored value, agentic commerce, and the changing economics of customer engagement.

